Architecture

By cliangNo Comments
ICS now totally utilitizes general computing equipment (server, workstatiom, OS, DB, communication) rather than developing own C&I. Therefore, OEM has to test the integration of machineries with these commodities sourced from the market. The industry has already defined the standard architecture how should the different types of components be zoned in the different network segments. Certain cybersecurity practitioners have misused the term architecture review. To be specific, it is the design review how is the design system deviated from the standard architecture, what are the ingress/egress points to the system, what is the worst scenario consequence and the anticipated likelihood to derive the optimal controls. We should not change the approved design by the OEM because they have validated the functionality and usability of the ICS to deliver the outcome. Catching security patches, new software version, adding extra firewall in between or even changing network layer protocol for perceived security could break the ICS. It will then be just like "The operation...
Read More

Improper Control #2

By cliangNo Comments
The detection should be deployed on the "risky" lane at junction Technical control is just one of the security measures. There are much surrounding elements to take care in order to secure. This includes but not limited to: Understand the security objectiveDesign with optimal controlsDeploy with the viable measures (be it technical, administrative or management controls)Verify if controls are deployed per designSustain the effectiveness of the controls Most often, security practitioners are focusing on technical controls with micro management. They forget the bigger picture where the technology stands in the entire business landscape. ...
Read More

Policy Making

By cliangNo Comments
For certain job roles of cybersecurity practitioners, policy making is necessary as a foundation in running the business securely to a reasonably degree. While doing so, we must fully understand the business objectives, operating environment and intended business outcomes taking text book knowledge as a reference rather than blindly applying. Where necessary, suitable qualifier or elaboration is required to enhance clarity. Example is personal privacy. The data subject must be a living individual shall have differentiated the situation in real life. Without this, it is impossible and impractical to enforce by replacing all the tombstone around the globe. ...
Read More

Stepping Stone #2

By cliangNo Comments
Jump hosts are typical used for remote access. These are controls: User accounts with multi-factor authenticationTime of day granted to this user accountRuleset to limit destination hosts when landed; and per login userSession monitoring On reasonable ground, some are mandatory while other extra measures depend. In extreme cases, multiple jump hosts are demanded that whether network latency, usability are at doubt. The optimal decision is to balance risk and usability with a hoslistic and objective assessment. Otherwise, it will be overkilled. ...
Read More

Physics #2

By cliangNo Comments
This is another great example to think deeper to balance cyber and physical world rather than just blindly putting unnecessary investment in cyber protection. There are researchers able to demonstrate remote control of the crane via a Casio watch. Is this scary? Without knowing the exploitation condition, management will be misinformed. We, as security practitioners, must analyze the situation, identify how this can be exploited before provide the correct message. The physical conditions of the crane must also be well under attention. Imagine a loosen bolt / nut, or erected at the improper foundation, incorrect procedure to extend the crane height could all result into the same catastrophic consequence. ...
Read More

Seasonal Factor #2

By cliangNo Comments
The Ice Road only opens Jan-Feb Anomalies detection highlights the technology will learn your environment as baseline reference such that "unusual" traffic will be flagged for alert. This will save detection ruleset definition but vendor always stresses short learning time (even just 1 or 2 weeks) to convince deployment for quick win demonstrating ROI. Sometimes, network traffic or application behaviors are seasonal based because of the business operations. Therefore as always, recurring maintenance efforts are required to sustain its effectiveness and don't be influenced by vendor for zero-deployment and zero-maintenance. ...
Read More

Usability

By cliangNo Comments
Everything is now undergoing digital transformation residing in the cyber space. Certain cybersecurity practitioners I met are overkilling business operations with cyber protection claiming to stay secure. Take the illustration above, the glass window provides scenery view from the room. If the reinforced steel covers are put on, it could definitely protect the glass window from strong wind during adverse weather. But if this steel covers are closed all the time, this will drive guests away affecting revenue. We need to be pragmatic and accept there are always risks from various domains to the business. And it's impractical to eliminate all risks. If you attempt doing so, it will end up "The operation was successful. The maharaja is dead." ...
Read More

Isolation

By cliangNo Comments
By common sense, systems isolated from the network will have immunity from cyber attack over the wire but still be vulnerable to infected removable media upon physical insertion. Just like the boat above. You don't worry about attack from sharks but what about crocodile in shallow water? As cybersecurity practitioner, we must have holistic understanding of the target operating environment, business objective and adverse consequence. We should not simply say my roles look after architecture and other issues need to talk to relevant team mates regarding cyber risks, cyber operations etc. With complete understanding, impose viable (not necessarily technical) controls for high impact consequence by reducing likelihood as much as practical. Don't just follow textbook knowledge - these are for reference only and must be digested what is applicable in own environment for helping asset owners with recommended optimal investment rather than overkill. Adding controls only creates complication and does not guarantee more secure. Indeed, more controls will demand...
Read More

“Insecure” Tunnel

By cliangNo Comments
Older TLS (Transport Layer Security) version is marked insecure by vulnerability scanner. Certain cybersecurity practitioners make decision solely based on scanner report and blindly to urge system admin to "fix" it without looking at the big picture. The vulnerability scanner has zero knowledge on the system landscape, criticality of the system being evaluated and most importantly where is the scanner placed in the network. Good practice is to assess the big picture, mark these are non-issues and forget it if it is just an internal system in isolated environment. Resources should be deployed on more important things. ...
Read More

Coverage

By cliangNo Comments
Security technology alone cannot reassure protection. It requires human judgment: What is the value of target being protected? Risks to low value asset or low business impact are simply accepted as part of the operating cost. Example is the anti-theft RFiD tags.How is the controls deployed? Is the control in place properly? Gap in control will leave a loop-hole.Most importantly, how is the control operated and sustained to maintain its effectiveness? Adding controls does not increase security sometimes but incur unnecessary overheads or activities that overkill the purpose. A comprehensive assessment from design, build, deploy, regular validation is required through out the life cycle of the deployed cybersecurity protection. ...
Read More